HEFT7 Let’s talk
Insights

PEOPLE

Mercenary or visionary?

Mercenaries can be titans of work. Visionaries more often build value. The difference does not always lie in competence. More often it lies in the answer to a question: why are we actually doing this?

HEFT7 Insights

On the left, rows of contractors at stacks of documents and checklists; on the right, a figure looking out at an open landscape of the future

In business it is very easy to confuse commitment with the number of hours worked. Someone is first in the office and last to leave, answers every message, watches every deadline and delivers exactly what was asked. That may be an excellent employee. But not necessarily the person who will change the company's result.

Because there is a difference between doing the work and taking responsibility for the outcome. And this is exactly where the difference between a mercenary and a visionary appears.

The mercenary asks: what should I do?

A mercenary may be superbly prepared. Disciplined, professional, reliable and very hardworking. They are given a task and they carry it out. The problem begins when completing the task stops being the same as achieving the goal.

Because business very rarely runs exactly according to instructions. The customer changes. The competition changes. Costs change. A problem appears that nobody anticipated. And then someone has to decide whether we keep executing the plan, or stop and ask: does what we are doing still make sense?

The visionary asks: what outcome are we trying to achieve?

A visionary does not have to work longer. But usually understands more broadly. They do not focus solely on their own task. They look at the interdependencies.

If a project was meant to increase sales and sales are not growing, the information "I did everything according to plan" is not enough for them. They want to know why. If a campaign is not working, a process is slowing down, a product is not reaching the customer or the team is not implementing the change, they start looking for the cause.

It is this difference that builds what we often call an ownership mindset. Responsibility not for activity. Responsibility for the outcome.

Visionaries make money

That sentence may sound provocative. But it is not about a "visionary" being a better person than a "mercenary". It is about a business mechanism.

A person who understands the purpose of what they do will notice sooner that something is not working. Will challenge a flawed assumption sooner. Will propose an alternative sooner. Will more often step outside their own remit when they see a problem that threatens the result. And above all, they can connect their own work with the economic outcome of the whole organisation.

That is why, very often, the greatest value is created not by the people who do the most work, but by those who best understand which work really matters.

Why the narrative matters so much

You cannot expect people to have a sense of mission if the organisation communicates only tasks: "Do this." "Implement that." "Close the project by the end of the quarter." These are instructions. Not a narrative.

If we want people to take responsibility for the outcome, they must understand:

  • Why are we doing this?
  • What are we trying to change?
  • What will happen if we change nothing?
  • What does success look like?
  • Why is this project more important than the ten other things we could also be doing?

That is why the question "why" matters so much. Not as a motivational slogan. As an element of management.

A strategy without a narrative remains a document

You can have an excellent strategy. You can have a detailed roadmap. You can have KPIs, governance, a schedule and a budget. And yet the transformation can stall.

Because people do not implement a PowerPoint. They implement a change whose purpose they must understand.

If an organisation cannot create a coherent narrative around the transformation, behaviour typical of the mercenary appears very quickly: "Tell me what to do." The visionary acts differently: "I understand what we are trying to achieve. Let's work out how best to get there."

Hard work is valuable. Direction is more valuable.

I am not belittling hard work. Quite the opposite. Without discipline, consistency and the ability to deliver, even the best vision remains a vision. But hard work alone does not create an advantage. An advantage appears when we combine: work, understanding, instinct and responsibility for the result.

That is why one of the most important questions you can ask a team is not: "Do you know what you have to do?" But: "Do you understand why we are doing it?" Because when the answer is truly clear, people stop merely carrying out tasks. They start building the result.

Related Insights

See all Insights

DECISIONS

The mystification of entrepreneurial fear

It is not always risk that paralyses. Often it is the vagueness of risk that does. Breaking a problem into specific elements makes it possible to name the risk, tame the fear and regain the ability to make decisions.

Read more

VALUE

Time is the primary currency.

It is not only about return on capital. In transformation, return on time matters just as much — which decisions deliver the greatest effect as quickly as possible.

Read more